New Patients: (516) 874-4041
Current Patients: (516) 747-2535
520 Franklin Ave, Suite 126, Garden City, NY 11530

About Our Garden City Dental Team

Tobin Dental Care in Garden City


Dr. Nancy Tobin

Dr. Nancy Tobin

Dr. Tobin has been practicing dentistry in Garden City for over 20 years with an ongoing belief that her patients deserve only the best care available. Her focus is blending total health, esthetics, and function to create smiles that look great and last a lifetime.

Since graduating from Georgetown University in 1989, Dr. Tobin has continued to further her skills in advanced dental techniques through ongoing education at some of the nation’s leading dental institutions including:

  • Dawson Center for the Advancement of Dentistry: A leading facility for comprehensive treatment of the entire masticatory (chewing) system with emphasis on occlusion and TMJ.
  • Spear Institute for Advanced Dental Education: A facility where focuses are blending high-tech developments with clinical artistry to diagnosis and treat complex dental cases.
  • Nash Institute for Dental Learning: A widely respected facility in North Carolina concentrated on advanced training and continuing education in cosmetic dentistry.

She remains active in several prominent dental societies, including the American Academy of Cosmetic Dentistry, the American Dental Association, and the Academy of General Dentistry.

Dr. Tobin is married to Mark Robertson and they are the proud parents of twins, Tim and Kate. She also goes by her married name of Dr. Nancy Robertson. The Robertsons’ share their home with Oreo, their giant, cuddly Great Dane.

Meet Our Team

Dental Hygienist

Paula has worked in the dental industry for over 25 years after receiving her Doctor of Dental Surgery (DDS) degree from Columbia University and her Registered Dental Hygienist (RDH) degree from NYU. She joined Dr. Tobin’s practice in 2015 after serving as a dental hygiene instructor at NYU, where she received the Long Island Odontology Award for Achievement in Clinical and Academic Studies. She also has additional training in sleep study protocol.

She loves being able to help patients achieve the best oral and overall health possible. In her free time, Paula is busy with her family, including her two children, and being active in various organizations such as St. Dominic Church and multiple schools.

Front Desk

Eileen has been working in the field of dentistry for over 35 years and joined our team back in 2018. She is in charge of scheduling patient appointments, maintaining patient records, and working on and presenting treatment plans to patients. She loves seeing the final results and the patient’s reaction to the care that they have received. She says that Dr. Tobin cares about every patient and truly goes the extra mile for everyone. She loves seeing all the advancements in technology that have changed throughout the years and enjoys learning about new techniques.

Outside of work, Eileen spends a lot of time doing volunteer work with animal-related organizations and fundraisers. She also loves spending time with her friends, nieces, and of course, pets.

Dental Assistant

Heather has been with our practice since the summer of 2019 and immediately became an integral part of the team. As a dental assistant, she is there to assist Dr. Tobin with a number of different procedures and interacts with nearly every single patient that we see. She loves that the people in the dental office truly care about the patient’s best interest, and never push unnecessary work on them.

Heather is a married mother of three girls who loves spending time with her family.

Dental Hygienist

While Isis has been working in dentistry for over 30 years (8 as a dental assistant, 22 as a hygienist), she only recently joined our practice. A graduate of NYC Technical College and Farmingdale State College, she’s currently working on her Masters degree in Dental Hygiene Education from MCPHS. A huge part of her job is education patients on oral hygiene and preventive care, as well as the connection that oral health has to the entire body’s health. She loves that she’s able to help make a difference in how patients view their own oral health as she builds a personal rapport with each patient.

Outside of work, Isis volunteers at a homeless food pantry, as well as working with Colgate BrightSmiles Oral Health Screening program. She loves traveling and meeting family and friends for lunch and dinner, and is going to be a proud grandmother in the next few months.

Front Desk

Maureen had been working in the dental field for over 27 years before joining our practice in the fall of 2019. She is the voice you hear on the phone when you are scheduling appointments, or when we reach out with reminders about coming in for preventive cleanings. She has a thirst for knowledge, and loves to learn about new advancements and techniques that could help make the patient’s experience more enjoyable.

Outside of work, Maureen volunteers with the Guide Dog Foundation and is often seen out taking walks with the dogs. She’s a mother of two as well as a grandmother and loves spending time with family and friends.

Tour Our Garden City Dental Practice

Dental Care

Are you embarrassed by the
appearance of your smile?


Need a permanent option
for missing teeth?


Did you know that snoring can
actually be a very serious problem?